OAFL Hall of Champions

Year
Champion
Coach
Score
Runner Up
Coach
1958
Calgary Chinooks
Terry Hurst
-
Long Island Sharks
Tom Meade
1959
Willistown Warriors
Andy Smith
-
-
-
1960
Seaside Savages
Scott Griffin
-
-
-
1961
Willistown Warriors
Andy Smith
-
-
-
1962
Lake Forest
-
-
-
-
1963
New Oxford Colonials
Jesse Elicker
49-20
Carolina Horsemen
-
1964
New Oxford Colonials
Jesse Elicker
42-14
Pittsburgh Peons
Lee Young
1965
Detroit Lions
Jay Lowrey
42-38
Forty West Sentinels
Martin Cole
1966
Pittsburgh Peons
Lee Young
27-19
Westchester Titans
Alan Raylesberg
1967
New Oxford Colonials
Jesse Elicker
40-17
Long Island Sharks
Tom Meade
1968
Kansas City Chiefs
Tony Giacobbe
30-21
New Oxford Colonials
Jesse Elicker
1969
Michigan Panthers
Carl Phillips
27-10
Texas Tornadoes
Crawford Davis
1970
Michigan Panthers
Carl Phillips
29-13
Massillon Tigers
Steve Zucchero
1971
Kansas City Chiefs
Tony Giacobbe
31-17
New Oxford Colonials
Jesse Elicker
1972
Forty West Sentinels
Martin Cole
21-17
Birmingham Dixie Kittens
Kevin Burke
1973
Cincinnati Bengals
John Storer
31-17
Colorado Tortoises
Keith Morse
1974
Frankford Yellow Jackets
Frank Costello
20-14
New Oxford Colonials
Jesse Elicker
1975
New Oxford Colonials
Jesse Elicker
27-3
Cincinnati Bengals
John Storer
1976
Illinois Enforcers
Kevin Kolb
38-14
New Oxford Colonials
Jesse Elicker
1977
New Oxford Colonials
Jesse Elicker
21-14
Illinois Enforcers
Kevin Kolb