Round 1	Round 2	Round 3	Round 4
1. Pittsburgh	(L) StL - Orlando Cepeda	Jim O'Toole	Willie Kirkland	Billy Moran
2. Washington	Vada Pinson	forfeit	John Buzhardt	Det - Alex Grammas
3. St. Louis	(L) Det - Norm Cash	Ken Johnson	Orlando Pena	Lenny Green
4. Detroit	(L) Pit - Bob Allison	Leon Wagner	Ron Hansen	Howie Reed
5. Philadelphia	Jim Grant	Dick Stuart	Norm Larker	Sammy Taylor
6. Cleveland	Tony Taylor	Johnny Romano	Pancho Herrera	Bobby Del Greco
7. Los Angeles	Frank Howard	Carl Willey	Ray Semproch	Bobby Gene Smith
8. Boston	Gary Bell	Bill Henry	Bob Schmidt	Humberto Robinson
9. Kansas City	Felipe Alou	forfeit	Don Lee	Charley Lau
10. Chicago	Stan Williams	Albie Pearson	Ted Bowsfield	Curt Raydon
11. Cincinnati	Johnny Callison	Dick Ellsworth	Gary Geiger	Herb Moford
12. Baltimore	Ron Fairly	forfeit	forfeit	forfeit
13. San Francisco	Jim Davenport	Ray Herbert	Willie Tasby	Phil Paine
14. New York Yankees	Bill Monboquette	Larry Sherry	Jerry Adair	Was - Joe Koppe

	Round 5	Round 6	Round 7	Round 8
1. Pittsburgh	Ruben Amaro	Bill Hall	pass	pass
2. Washington	Elmer Singleton	Danny McDevitt	Mike Garcia	pass
3. St. Louis	Del Ennis	Sal Maglie	Paul Giel	pass
4. Detroit	Steve Ridzik	Seth Morehead	John Romonosky	Willy Miranda
5. Philadelphia	Ron Blackburn	Bob Lillis	Jerry Casale	Carroll Hardy
6. Cleveland	NYY - Chuck Essegian	Harry Bright	Nelson Chittum	pass
7. Los Angeles	Hal Griggs	John Briggs	Don Mueller	Whitey Lockman
8. Boston	Johnny Goryl	Zach Monroe	Pete Whisenant	Danny Kravitz
9. Kansas City	NYY - Earl Averill	Fred Kipp	Bill Wight	Bob Giallombardo
10. Chicago	Bob Mabe	Ossie Alvarez	Charlie Beamon	Tom Qualters
11. Cincinnati	Ed Mayer	Marv Throneberry	Mike Baxes	Babe Birrer
12. Baltimore	forfeit	forfeit	Joe Ginsberg	Coot Veal
13. San Francisco	Marty Keough	Bob Smith	Neil Chrisley	Gene Fodge
14. New York Yankees	Jim Marshall	R.C. Stevens	pass	pass